FAQ
Q.
There are so many variables with antennas. How accurate can those tables be?
A. They were obtained from mathematic calculations, but
they should provide a good starting point.
Q. I realize the diagram is simplified down to the very basic; but
what about lightning protection?
A. The coaxial cable feed line should be disconnected from the transmitter/receiver and attached to a good
ground whenever nearby lightning activity is eminent.
Q. In the diagram, it should be noted that some of the RF energy
from the transmitter will travel back down on the outside of the coax feed line. That will make the feed line a radiator
close to you.
A. One
way to prevent that from happening is to wrap about 20 feet of the coax into a coil near to the antenna feed point.
That should choke off the unwanted RF.
Q. An antenna I used for several years back in the 50's and into the 60's was just what you describe and it worked fine.
In 1954, as a novice using a single 6L6 crystal controlled oscillator as my transmitter, I had many favorable QSO's on
80 meters. So, even if the balanced antenna is fed with unbalanced coax line, it does radiate. When I upgraded to General and used a Heath AT-1 with an 813 Amplifier running
about 250 watts input, I had RF in the shack. I suspect the condition was there all along but was never realized because
of the low power. I then learned about a balanced transmission line and added a length of coax in parallel with the
main feeder from the center of the antenna to a point 1/4 wavelength down the line where I bonded the 2nd coax outer shield
to the main feeder coax shield. That solved the problem of RF in the shack although I never noted any difference
in performance of the antenna.
A. For simplicity and lowest cost, it is hard to beat a good old reliable half-wave dipole. See
BE Informed No. 41 for a discussion of my similar 1954 Novice station.
Q. Isn't it typical to work on your antenna when it is the worst weather possible? At least
that is the way it seems to always turn out. I thought antenna work was to be done when it was windy and raining or
snowing. From my experience antenna work done at these times always provided the best results.
A. It seems that way.
An antenna erected on a nice warm sunny day never seems to perform as desired.
An antenna that
stayed up last winter just wasn't high enough.
April 4, 2011
Supersedes all prior editions